25 Easy Heart-Shaped Dessert Recipes to Make Valentine’s Day Extra Sweet

Heads up! We may use affiliate links in this post. You'll never pay more, but we might earn a small commission if you buy - thanks for supporting us! See our full disclosure here.

I have a soft spot for heart-shaped desserts, and I’m not sorry about it. It’s nostalgic, a little extra in a low-stakes way, and somehow manages to make even the simplest recipe feel intentional.

Valentine’s Day doesn’t have to mean a complicated menu or a sink full of dishes—sometimes it’s just an excuse to bake something sweet, cut it into a heart, and enjoy the small rituals that make the day feel special.

---

PIN FOR LATER

---

These heart-shaped dessert recipes are exactly that.

Nothing fussy, nothing intimidating—just fun, approachable ideas that work for breakfast, dessert, or whatever version of the day you’re celebrating.

Think recipes you’d actually make on a weeknight, share with someone you love, or save for when you want a little joy on a plate.

1. Valentine Sugar Cookies

These heart-shaped sugar cookies keep things classic in the best way—crisp edges, soft centres, and just enough chocolate to make them feel special.

GO TO RECIPE

---

MORE VALENTINE’S DAY POSTS:

15 Valentine’s Day Sugar Cookies That Are Perfectly Decorated

18 Valentine’s Day Mason Jar Crafts That Make Gifting Feel Personal Again

14 Creative Valentine’s Day Letterbox Crafts To Make With Love

21 Short Valentine’s Day Nail Ideas That Feel Chic, Not Cheesy

12 Virtual Valentine’s Day Ideas for Long-Distance Love and Low-Key Plans

24 Creative Ideas For A Fun Valentine’s Day Game Night

---

2. Puff Pastry Berry Hearts

Flaky heart-shaped pastries filled with whipped cream and fresh raspberries feel light, sweet, and just right for Valentine’s Day.

GO TO RECIPE

3. Easy Chocolate Peanut Butter Hearts

Rich, chocolate-covered heart treats that feel classic, indulgent, and perfect for Valentine’s Day gifting.

GO TO RECIPE

4. Heart-Shaped Cupcakes

These heart-topped cupcakes are soft, classic, and finished with pink frosting that feels festive without trying too hard.

GO TO RECIPE

5. Salted Caramel Brownies

Fudgy heart-shaped brownies with a gooey caramel centre and a pinch of flaky salt for balance.

GO TO RECIPE

6. Rice Krispies Valentine Lollipops

Heart-shaped Rice Krispies treats coated in sprinkles make an easy, no-bake Valentine’s Day dessert.

GO TO RECIPE

7. Valentine Cookie Cake

A heart-shaped chocolate chip cookie cake topped with swirls of frosting for an easy Valentine’s Day dessert that always delivers.

GO TO RECIPE

RELATED: 18 Valentine’s Day Cake Recipes Worth Baking

8. Heart-Shaped Cookies

Heart-shaped sugar cookies decorated with simple icing and sweet messages feel nostalgic in the best Valentine’s Day way.

GO TO RECIPE

9. Heart-Shaped S’more Cookies

Heart-topped s’mores squares combine chocolate, graham crackers, and toasted marshmallow for an easy Valentine’s treat.

GO TO RECIPE

10. Heart-Shaped Chocolate Tarts

These heart-shaped chocolate tarts pair a crisp graham crust with a rich filling for a Valentine’s dessert that feels extra special.

GO TO RECIPE

11. Strawberry Cream Cheese Breakfast Pastries

Heart-shaped strawberry pastries with a soft centre and flaky edges feel fresh, sweet, and perfect for Valentine’s Day.

GO TO RECIPE

12. Chocolate Covered Peanut Butter Hearts

Chocolate-covered peanut butter hearts are rich, nostalgic, and surprisingly easy to make at home.

GO TO RECIPE

13. Valentine’s Day Sandwich Cookies

These heart-shaped chocolate sandwich cookies with pink filling feel nostalgic, festive, and perfect for Valentine’s Day sharing.

GO TO RECIPE

14. Cinnamon Orange Valentine Cookies

Assorted heart-shaped sugar cookies decorated in shades of pink and red feel festive, nostalgic, and fun to customise.

GO TO RECIPE

15. Puff Pastry Hearts With Cherries

Heart-shaped cherry hand pies with flaky edges and a glossy filling feel nostalgic in the best Valentine’s Day way.

GO TO RECIPE

16. Heart-Shaped Cinnamon Rolls

Heart-shaped cinnamon rolls with a soft centre and vanilla glaze feel perfect for a Valentine’s Day morning.

GO TO RECIPE

17. Heart Lollipops

Heart-shaped chocolate lollipops feel fun and nostalgic, perfect for Valentine’s Day treats or party favours.

GO TO RECIPE

18. Churros Recipe with Chocolate Sauce

Heart-shaped churros coated in cinnamon sugar and drizzled with chocolate feel playful and perfect for Valentine’s Day.

GO TO RECIPE

19. Valentine Lollipop Treats

Heart-shaped chocolate pops with hand-piped “love” details feel festive, nostalgic, and perfect for Valentine’s Day gifting.

GO TO RECIPE

20. Heart-Shaped Strawberry Hand Pies

Heart-shaped strawberry hand pies finished with a pink glaze feel fresh, nostalgic, and perfect for Valentine’s Day.

GO TO RECIPE

21. Strawberry Conversation Heart Cake

A heart-shaped frosted cake with a playful message feels perfect for a low-key, stay-in Valentine’s celebration.

GO TO RECIPE

22. Red Velvet Mini Cakes

Mini heart-shaped red velvet cakes layered with cream cheese frosting feel indulgent without being too heavy.

GO TO RECIPE

23. Heart-Shaped Hostess Cupcake Cookies

Heart-shaped chocolate cookies topped with glossy frosting feel indulgent and perfect for Valentine’s Day baking.

GO TO RECIPE

24. Valentine’s Day Pretzel Hearts

These Valentine’s Day pretzel hearts hit that sweet-and-salty sweet spot, finished with melted chocolate and conversation hearts.

GO TO RECIPE

25. Coloured Marble Cookies

Conversation heart sugar cookies with stamped messages bring a fun, modern twist to a Valentine’s classic.

GO TO RECIPE

SEE ALSO:

• 18 Valentine’s Day Cake Recipes Worth Baking
• 17 Valentine’s Day Cupcake Recipes That Are Almost Too Pretty To Eat (Almost)
• 6 Valentine’s Day Mocktail Recipes That Sparkle With Romance